LegendFlame Carl 28" Insert vs RICHFLAME Edward 33" Insert
LegendFlame Carl 28" Insert
Best for: An old wood or gas firebox you no longer burn and want to bring back to life
Last price we saw
$300
Score 5.9 out of 10
Prices move a lot, and most fireplaces go on sale in November and again after New Year. The store shows the current price. We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you. More on that.
RICHFLAME Edward 33" Insert
Best for: An old wood or gas firebox you no longer burn and want to bring back to life
Last price we saw
$360
Score 6.0 out of 10
Prices move a lot, and most fireplaces go on sale in November and again after New Year. The store shows the current price. We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you. More on that.
Our verdict
- The RICHFLAME Edward 33" Insert is 6 inches wider (35 against 29 in).
- On overall score the RICHFLAME Edward 33" Insert comes out ahead (6.0 to 5.9).
| LegendFlame Carl 28" Insert | RICHFLAME Edward 33" Insert | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $300 | $360 |
| Type | Fireplace insert | Fireplace insert |
| Size | 28.7"W x 10.4"D x 21.3"H | 35"W x 8.8"D x 27"H |
| Heater | 1,500 W (5,118 BTU) | 1,500 W (5,118 BTU) |
| Heats up to | 400 sq ft | 400 sq ft |
| Thermostat | Yes | not published |
| Flame without heat | Yes | Yes |
| Flame colors | not published | not published |
| Crackling sound | Yes | Yes |
| Remote control | Yes | Yes |
| Phone app | not published | not published |
| Timer | not published | not published |
| Fuel bed | Log set | Log set |
| Fits a TV up to | not published | not published |
| Safety listing | not published | CSA |
| Overheat cut-off | not published | Yes |
| Color / finish | not published | not published |
| Weight | 46 lb | 55.7 lb |
| Warranty | not published | not published |
| Score | 5.9 / 10 | 6.0 / 10 |